Asphalt roofing and metal roofing are two of the most popular types of roofing we see in our backyard. To properly compare them, we will take a closer look at both of them. We will also record which material is more durable, which option is better for energy efficiency, how much you’ll save on maintenance costs, and more.

After doing enough research to come up with a more precise comparison of the two options, we found that metal roofing is a better alternative for homeowners. The most crucial drawback of this type of roofing is its price.

With the average metal roof costing about $6,500, it may seem like an expensive option for people who do not have their house paid off in time. However, this doesn’t mean that asphalt roofs are more worth it.

Metal roofs are more durable, maintenance-free, and environmentally friendly. It is important to note that asphalt roofs need regular maintenance, as it does not last a lifetime. They are also prone to leaks when they wear out, so you might be replacing them more often than you think.

Asphalt roofing can also get damaged by pests like termites, dry rot, or wood-destroying fungi if they infest your home. Lastly, you will have to pay your roofer extra for installing metal roofs.

Cost Comparison

Metal Roofing: $6,500

Asphalt Roofing: $4,900 (usually between $2,500 and $3,000 for a home with a sloped roof)

When comparing these options, the first thing that comes to mind is the price difference. Most people may think that asphalt roofing is a more affordable option, but they are wrong. Asphalt roofs cost about $1,000 less than metal roofs, but you will have to pay this money every year or so because of regular maintenance work.

Also, asphalt roofs cannot stand the test of time. They wear out quickly and may even need to be replaced within a few years.

Maintenance Cost

Metal Roofing: $0

Asphalt Roofing: $1,500

Replacing a roof is a big hassle, and homeowners dread the idea of needing to hire people to do it. As stated above, metal roofs do not need regular maintenance work or repairs. This is one reason why they are so popular. If something goes wrong, you will have to find a roofer who will be willing to fix your problem for an additional cost.

On the other hand, an asphalt roof will need to be serviced regularly because they wear out so often. You must check for leaks in your roof every few weeks and call a professional if you detect any signs of damage.

You must also check the pitch of your roof every time it rains to make sure water doesn’t accumulate on it. Other than that, you should clean your gutters regularly and get them inspected by a qualified professional from time to time as well.


Metal Roofing: 90% of their lifetime costs are saved during their lifetime

Asphalt Roofing: 50% of their lifetime costs are saved during their lifetime.

This means that you’ll be spending $1,500 for a roof that will only save you $750 in energy bills. This is one more reason you might want to look into metal roofs because they do not need regular maintenance work, and they pay off much quicker than asphalt roofs.


Metal Roofing: 50-100 years

Asphalt Roofing: 20-30 years

One of the biggest differences between these two types of roofing is how long they last. Asphalt roofs start to deteriorate after a few years, and once it has damaged, you will need to spend much money on fixing or replacing it.

However, metal roofs are known to last much longer. A metal roof can last for 50-100 years, depending on the number of factors that come into play. Usually, metal roofs do not need to be replaced until people move out of their homes.

Energy Efficiency

Metal Roofing: 69%

Asphalt Roofing: 8% of energy is saved when compared to asphalt roofing. This is one reason why metal roofs are a better option for homeowners who want to cut their energy costs. Metal roofs are slightly less efficient than asphalt roofs, but they still improve your home’s energy efficiency.

Metal roofing might seem like an expensive option for people trying to get their homes repaired because they do not have the money to spend. However, you should look at the bigger picture and see how affordable it is in the long run. You will no longer need to pay for regular maintenance work or repairs, which is why you won’t need to replace your roof very often.

This post was written by a roofing professional at KCG Roofing. KCG Roofing is a premier roofing contractor in Florida! KCG Roofing has the experience and expertise to replace or repair your roof with quality materials and excellent craftsmanship. All our roofs are backed by a 15-year leak-free guarantee, the highest in the industry. We have been family-owned and operated for over 40 years. Click here to learn more.

Related Posts